Q.46 Given below are two statements: One is labelled as Assertion (A) and the other is labelled as Reason (R):
Assertion (A): Tropical regions have higher biodiversity as compared to other regions of earth.
Reason (R): Tropical regions have older communities and they get more time for development and speciation as compared to other regions of earth.
In the light of the above statements, choose the most appropriate answer from the options given below:
- Both (A) and (R) are correct and (R) is the correct explanation of (A)
- Both (A) and (R) are correct but (R) is NOT the correct explanation of (A)
- (A) is correct but (R) is not correct
- (A) is not correct but (R) is correct
Tropical regions exhibit higher biodiversity than temperate or polar areas due to favorable conditions, while the idea of “older communities” providing more speciation time is debated but not the primary explanation.
Question Breakdown
Assertion (A) states tropical regions have higher biodiversity compared to other earth regions. Reason (R) claims tropical regions have older communities with more time for development and speciation.
This tests ecological latitudinal diversity gradient knowledge, common in Life Sciences exams.
Assertion (A): Correct
Tropics host over 50% of global species despite covering ~10% land area. Examples: Amazon rainforests with millions of insect species; coral reefs with vast marine diversity.
Reason (R): Partially Correct but Questionable
Tropical communities are stable with less glaciation, allowing longer evolutionary history. However, high speciation rates balance high extinction; tropics act as both “cradle” (new species) and “museum” (old lineages). Not solely time-based.
Option Analysis
-
Both correct, R explains A: Incorrect; R offers one factor but ignores climate stability, energy, habitat diversity as main drivers.
-
Both correct, R NOT explanation: Correct answer; A true, R contributes but not primary (solar energy, predictability key).
-
A correct, R incorrect: Incorrect; R has validity despite not fully explaining.
-
A incorrect, R correct: Wrong; A firmly established fact.
Key Explanations for Higher Diversity
Tropics show greater species richness via:
-
Climate Stability: Predictable warmth, rainfall enable year-round growth, complex food webs.
-
Solar Energy: High productivity supports more niches, trophic levels.
-
Habitat Variety: Rainforests, mangroves create microhabitats.
-
Evolutionary Time: Less disturbance preserves lineages.
| Factor |
Tropical Advantage |
Temperate Contrast |
| Energy Input |
High year-round |
Seasonal limits |
| Disturbance |
Low (no ice ages) |
High glaciations |
| Niches |
Abundant, stable |
Fewer, variable |
| Speciation Rate |
Elevated |
Lower |
Primary drivers: energy and stability over age alone. Ideal for plant sciences, ecology exam prep.