Q.43 A human gene has only three exons (I, II and III in the given order). Total RNA was isolated from
cultured human kidney cells and reverse transcribed. The resultant cDNA was used as a template in
a PCR reaction containing a forward primer specific to Exon I and a reverse primer specific to Exon
III. When the PCR product was analyzed by gel electrophoresis, two bands were observed of sizes
2.5 kb and 1 kb. However, when Northern blotting was performed with the same total RNA using a
radiolabeled probe specific to Exon II, only one band was observed. Based on these observations,
which one of the following statements is FALSE ?
(A) Northern blotting with a probe specific to Exon III will show two bands.
(B) The gene codes for two mRNA splice variants.
(C) If the forward primer were specific to Exon II, two bands will be observed.
(D) The Exon II is 1.5 kb in size.
PCR with primers in Exon I and Exon III on cDNA yields two bands (2.5 kb and 1 kb), indicating two mRNA splice variants present in kidney cells, but Northern blotting with an Exon II probe shows only one band, meaning Exon II appears in just one variant. Option (D) is false because Exon II cannot be 1.5 kb, as that size difference would not match the PCR band gap.
Understanding the Experiment
Total RNA from human kidney cells undergoes reverse transcription to cDNA, followed by PCR using a forward primer in Exon I and reverse primer in Exon III. Gel electrophoresis reveals two distinct bands at 2.5 kb and 1 kb, confirming two different cDNA products spanning Exons I to III. Northern blotting of the same RNA with a radiolabeled Exon II-specific probe detects only one band, indicating Exon II exists in only one mature mRNA isoform expressed in these cells.
Splice Variant Explanation
The gene produces two mRNA splice variants: one includes all three exons (I-II-III, size 2.5 kb), while the other skips Exon II (I-III direct join, size 1 kb). The 1.5 kb difference between PCR bands matches the size of Exon II, as both products share Exon I and III but differ solely by inclusion or exclusion of Exon II. Northern blot confirms this, as the Exon II probe hybridizes only to the full-length variant containing Exon II.
Option-by-Option Analysis
-
(A) True: A probe specific to Exon III would detect both bands on Northern blot, since Exon III appears in both splice variants (I-II-III and I-III).
-
(B) True: Two PCR bands directly evidence two mRNA splice variants from alternative splicing of the three-exon gene.
-
(C) True: Forward primer in Exon II (reverse in Exon III) amplifies only the variant with Exon II (I-II-III), but no—wait, cDNA from kidney cells contains both variants; primer in Exon II yields one band (2.5 kb minus Exon I size, but since Exon I primer was not used, actually: Exon II forward would amplify from Exon II-III in the full variant only, as skipped variant lacks Exon II entirely, producing one band.
-
(D) False: Exon II size equals the PCR band difference (2.5 kb – 1 kb = 1.5 kb), but Northern shows one band for Exon II probe; if Exon II were 1.5 kb, it fits perfectly, wait—no contradiction? Actually, the claim is possible, but question asks FALSE statement; re-eval: all seem true? No—PCR bands reflect total span I-III; difference is Exon II size (1.5 kb), Northern one band confirms Exon II in one variant only. But (D) states “The Exon II is 1.5 kb in size”—this is TRUE based on math. Wait, error in reasoning: actually, upon precise logic, (D) is TRUE, but question data implies FALSE is (A)? No.
Correct false: (D) is FALSE because Northern one band with Exon II probe means Exon II present in one mRNA, but if Exon II were 1.5 kb, PCR difference holds, but option (C): forward Exon II primer would amplify ONLY the variant WITH Exon II (Exon II to III fragment), producing ONE band, not two, as skipped variant lacks Exon II—no binding site. Thus (C) claims “two bands”—FALSE.
| Option | Statement | True/False | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| (A) | Northern Exon III probe: two bands | True | Exon III in both variants |
| (B) | Gene codes two mRNA splice variants | True | Two PCR bands confirm |
| (C) | Forward primer Exon II: two bands | False | Only amplifies variant with Exon II; one band |
| (D) | Exon II is 1.5 kb | True | PCR size difference (2.5-1=1.5 kb) |


