Q.41 A researcher wants to clone 3 DNA fragments of sizes 1.1 Mb, 0.097 Mb and 0.045 Mb. The choice of the vectors for cloning each of the fragments are: (A) Cosmid, bacteriophage λ, bacteriophage P1 (B) Yeast artificial chromosome, bacteriophage P1, cosmid (C) Bacterial artificial chromosome, bacteriophage λ, yeast artificial chromosome (D) Only plasmids

Q.41 A researcher wants to clone

3 DNA fragments of sizes
1.1 Mb,
0.097 Mb and
0.045 Mb.
The choice of the vectors for cloning each of the fragments are:

(A) Cosmid, bacteriophage λ, bacteriophage P1

(B) Yeast artificial chromosome, bacteriophage P1, cosmid

(C) Bacterial artificial chromosome, bacteriophage λ, yeast artificial chromosome

(D) Only plasmids

Introduction

In molecular biology, the selection of a suitable cloning vector depends mainly on the
size of the DNA fragment. Competitive examinations such as CSIR-NET, GATE,
DBT, and JAM often test this concept by asking candidates to match DNA fragment sizes with
appropriate cloning vectors.

Problem Statement

A researcher wants to clone three DNA fragments of sizes:

  • 1.1 Mb
  • 0.097 Mb (97 kb)
  • 0.045 Mb (45 kb)

Cloning Capacity of Common Vectors

  • Plasmids: up to 10 kb
  • Bacteriophage λ: 10–20 kb
  • Cosmid: 35–45 kb
  • Bacteriophage P1: 70–100 kb
  • Bacterial Artificial Chromosome (BAC): 100–300 kb
  • Yeast Artificial Chromosome (YAC): 200 kb to >1 Mb

Step-by-Step Vector Selection

Fragment 1 (1.1 Mb): This very large DNA fragment can only be cloned using
a Yeast Artificial Chromosome (YAC).

Fragment 2 (0.097 Mb): This fragment (~97 kb) falls within the optimal range
of bacteriophage P1.

Fragment 3 (0.045 Mb): A fragment of ~45 kb is ideally cloned using a
cosmid.

Correct Answer

Option (B): Yeast artificial chromosome, bacteriophage P1, cosmid

Explanation of All Options

Option (A): Cosmid, bacteriophage λ, bacteriophage P1

Cosmids cannot accommodate 1.1 Mb DNA, and bacteriophage λ cannot clone a 97 kb fragment.
Hence, this option is incorrect.

Option (B): Yeast artificial chromosome, bacteriophage P1, cosmid

YAC efficiently clones DNA fragments larger than 1 Mb, P1 is suitable for ~100 kb inserts,
and cosmids are ideal for ~45 kb DNA. This option correctly matches vector capacity with
fragment size.

Option (C): Bacterial artificial chromosome, bacteriophage λ, yeast artificial chromosome

BACs cannot clone 1.1 Mb DNA, bacteriophage λ is unsuitable for 97 kb fragments,
and using YAC for 45 kb DNA is impractical. Therefore, this option is incorrect.

Option (D): Only plasmids

Plasmids cannot clone DNA fragments larger than 10 kb and are completely unsuitable
for all three fragments. Hence, this option is incorrect.

Conclusion

Correct selection of cloning vectors is based on the insert size. In this problem,
a combination of YAC, bacteriophage P1, and cosmid provides the most
efficient and biologically accurate solution. Understanding vector capacity is essential
for solving cloning-based questions in competitive exams.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Courses