- A researcher working on island biogeography mapped how isolation-controlled immigration (l), and area-controlled extinction (E), will act on number of species present on the islands. He forgot to label the size of the islands (small or large) and the location of the islands (near or far) on the graph.
Using information from MacArthhur and Wilson’s equilibrium theory, select the option that correctly identifies A, B, C and D in the figure above.
(1) A-large, B-small, C-near, D-far
(2) A-small, B-large, C-far, D-near
(3) A-near, B-far, C-small, D-large
(4) A-far, B-near, C-large, D-smallThe Core Principles
-
Immigration Rate: Highest for islands closest to the mainland (near islands), as more species can easily reach them. Immigration rate decreases for distant (far) islands.
-
Extinction Rate: Lowest on large islands, which offer more resources and habitats, reducing competition and supporting larger populations. Extinction rate is higher on small islands due to limited resources and higher vulnerability to random events.
Understanding the Curves
-
Immigration Curves:
-
Near islands have higher immigration rates at any given number of species, so their curve is positioned higher on the graph.
-
Far islands have lower immigration rates, so their curve is lower.
-
-
Extinction Curves:
-
Large islands have lower extinction rates, so their curve is lower.
-
Small islands have higher extinction rates, so their curve is higher.
-
Matching Labels to Graph Features
Given the options and the logic above, here’s how the labels typically map:
-
A (Immigration curve for near or far): Higher immigration = near; lower immigration = far.
-
B (Immigration curve for the other): The opposite of A.
-
C (Extinction curve for small or large): Higher extinction = small; lower extinction = large.
-
D (Extinction curve for the other): The opposite of C.
Applying the Theory to the Options
From the search results and established theory:
-
Large islands have lower extinction rates (extinction curve is lower).
-
Small islands have higher extinction rates (extinction curve is higher).
-
Near islands have higher immigration rates (immigration curve is higher).
-
Far islands have lower immigration rates (immigration curve is lower)12346.
Now, match the options:
-
A-large, B-small, C-near, D-far
-
A-small, B-large, C-far, D-near
-
A-near, B-far, C-small, D-large
-
A-far, B-near, C-large, D-small
The correct mapping, based on the classic model, is:
-
A: Near (higher immigration)
-
B: Far (lower immigration)
-
C: Small (higher extinction)
-
D: Large (lower extinction)
This matches Option 3: A-near, B-far, C-small, D-large.
Conclusion
According to MacArthur and Wilson’s equilibrium theory of island biogeography, the correct identification of A, B, C, and D in the model is:
A – near, B – far, C – small, D – large
(Option 3) -
1 Comment
Kajal
October 10, 2025Option 3 is correct